Looking fora Milkshake alternative?

One scrolling page instead of swipeable cards. Here's how they compare.

Facts checked on 5 November 2026

Dusk · Classic
Coach LouSurf and strength coaching
NEWFree 7-day surf fitness planBook a sessionBoard guideTips every SundayYour emailJoin
Daydream · Banner
Nails by JoGel, BIAB and nail art, Bristol
Book a setYour first set, 15% offJOSNAILSPrice listMessage me
+412 sign-ups
Arcade · Hero
DJ KofiHouse and garage, Fri nights
Late Night Mix Vol. 342 min · SoundCloudLive at Corsica StudiosTour datesBookings
1,204 clicks
Picnic · Classic
Maya BakesSmall-batch bakes, Leeds
SELLING FASTThis week’s box: chocolate dripOrder a boxCookie club10% off your first boxHIYA10
Zine · Minimal
@fernfigFERN & FIGHouseplants, delivered
£24The easy-care bundleShop plantsPlant care guide

Milkshake and Hiyaly, side by side

Drag across to compare the two homepages. Both are real screenshots, taken the same week.

Screenshots of milkshake.app and hiyaly.com, taken 5 November 2026. Milkshake is a trademark of its owner; we're not affiliated.

The short answer

Milkshake lets you build a free mini website on your phone, made of Cards visitors swipe through, and it can sell digital files for a fee of 7% to 12%. Hiyaly is one link-in-bio page for $8 a month, set up by Hiya from your socials, and it takes no cut on downloads, tips or paid bookings. Pick Milkshake for free; pick Hiyaly for messages, scheduled links and a verified badge.

Pick Milkshake if

You want a free page that stays free.
You like a swipeable, multi-page site made of Cards.
You want a free plan that can sell digital files.
You want to remove branding for the lowest price ($2.99 a month).

Milkshake's plans

Lite · $2.99/month
Pro · $6.99/month
Pro+ · $10/month

Pick Hiyaly if

You'd rather not give up 7% to 12% of what you sell.
You want visitors to message you and a verified badge checked by a person.
You want scheduled links and a link shortener built in.
You want your page started from your socials, not from an old page.

Build your page

At a glance

Price: Milkshake:Free, then $2.99 to $10/month; Hiyaly:$8/month or $72/year per page
Free plan: Milkshake:Yes; Hiyaly:No free plan; 14-day free trial, then $8/month
Fees on sales: Milkshake:7% to 12%, plus Stripe; Hiyaly:0% Hiyaly fee; Stripe processing only
Layout: Milkshake:Swipeable Cards, like Stories; Hiyaly:One scrolling page
Setup: Milkshake:Paste a Linktree or website and it builds a draft; Hiyaly:Hiya brings in your photo, bio and links from your socials
Remove branding: Milkshake:Lite, $2.99/month; Hiyaly:Pro, $8/month
Email sign-ups: Milkshake:Pro, $6.99/month; Hiyaly:Pro, $8/month

What a year costs

The cheapest paid plan on each, for one page.

Milkshake$35.88/yr

Hiyaly Pro$96/yr

Fees on sales, Milkshake: 12% on Free and Lite, 9% on Pro, 7% on Pro+, plus Stripe's fee
Fees on sales, Hiyaly: 0% platform fees: Stripe's standard processing only

Cheapest paid plan for one page, billed monthly where both offer it, as listed on 5 November 2026. Hiyaly is priced per page, and is $72 a year if you pay yearly; Milkshake's plans may cover more. Prices change, so check Milkshake's pricing page before you decide.

Feature by feature

Feature	Milkshake	Hiyaly
Publish a page for free	Yes	No14-day free trial, then $8/month; build and preview first
Themes and custom design	YesLooks with your colors, fonts and logo	Yes
Videos that play on the page	YesYouTube videos on Cards	YesYouTube, Vimeo and TikTok
Email sign-ups	PartlyMailing list on Pro	Yes
Send sign-ups to your email tool	PartlyGoogle Sheets and Mailchimp on Pro	YesMailchimp, Klaviyo, Kit and more, or CSV export
Sell products with built-in checkout	YesDigital files with Stripe; 7% to 12% fee	YesDownloads and tips through your own Stripe, 0% platform fees
Built-in bookings	NoContact form for booking requests on Pro	YesGoogle Calendar and Meet; paid sessions at 0% platform fees
Click analytics	Yes30 days free, 365 days on Pro	YesLast 90 days
Scheduled links	PartlyCan hide Cards on Pro; scheduling not listed	Yes
Your own domain	PartlyPro+	YesIncluded in Pro
Remove the tool's branding	PartlyLite and up	Yes
Verified badge	NoNot listed on their site	YesChecked by a person
Builds your page from your socials	PartlyBuilds a draft from your Linktree or website link	YesHiya sets it up from Instagram, TikTok, YouTube or X
Link shortener	NoNot listed on their site	YesWith click counts
QR code for your page	Yes	Yes
Messages from visitors	PartlyContact form on Pro	Yes
Meta and Google pixels	PartlyMeta pixel on Pro; Google Analytics on Pro+	Yes
Password-protected page	NoNot listed on their site	Yes

Why people switch from Milkshake

1
No cut of your sales
Milkshake keeps 12% of sales on Free and Lite, 9% on Pro and 7% on Pro+. Hiyaly takes 0% on downloads, tips and paid bookings; only Stripe's processing applies.
2
Set up from your socials
Milkshake can build a draft from a page you already have. Hiya works from Instagram, TikTok, YouTube or X, so you don't need an old page to start from.
3
Sign-ups included
Email sign-ups and messages come with Hiyaly Pro at $8 a month. On Milkshake, the mailing list and contact form need Pro at $6.99.
4
Scheduled links and a badge
Hiyaly lets you schedule links to go live, and a real person checks every verified badge. Milkshake doesn't list either.

Cards or one page

A Milkshake site is a set of Cards. Each Card is like a page, and visitors swipe between them like Instagram Stories. You might have one Card for links, one for an About page and one for products. You build and edit it in the Milkshake app for iPhone and Android.

Hiyaly is one scrolling page. Everything is in one place: your links, videos, sign-ups and messages. If you need separate pages for separate projects, you can make more than one page, each with its own plan.

Selling and what it costs

Milkshake lets you sell digital files with Stripe on every plan. The fee depends on your plan: 12% on Free and Lite, 9% on Pro and 7% on Pro+, with Stripe's fee on top.

Say you sell a $50 file 20 times a month. That's $1,000 in sales, and Milkshake keeps $120 on Free, $90 on Pro or $70 on Pro+.

Hiyaly sells digital files too, and takes 0% on them. Sales are charged on your own Stripe account, so on the same $1,000 you'd pay Stripe's processing and nothing to Hiyaly.

The plans side by side

Milkshake Lite is $2.99 a month and removes branding. Pro is $6.99 a month or $59.99 a year, and adds a mailing list, contact form, Meta pixel and a year of analytics. Pro+ is $99.99 a year or $29.99 a quarter, and adds your own domain and Google Analytics. Prices can vary by country and app store, and there's no free trial.

Hiyaly has one plan, Pro, at $8 a month or $72 a year. It covers publishing, no branding, sign-ups sent to Mailchimp, Klaviyo, Kit and more, messages, scheduled links, 90 days of analytics, Meta and Google pixels, a password-protected page and a verified badge.

Move from Milkshake to Hiyaly

1
Sign up at hiyaly.com and tell Hiya where you post.
2
Add the links from your Milkshake Cards that Hiya didn't bring in.
3
If you sell files on Milkshake, upload them to your Hiyaly shop.
4
Pick a theme and preview it, then choose Pro to publish.
5
Swap your msha.ke link for your Hiyaly link in each bio.

Go live free for 14 days, no card needed. Then $8 a month, or $72 a year.

Frequently asked questions

Is Hiyaly free?

There's no free plan, but there's a 14-day free trial on Pro, monthly or yearly, with no card needed. After that it's $8 a month, or $72 a year, per page. Milkshake has a free plan you can publish on.

Can I move my Milkshake links to Hiyaly?

Yes. Hiya brings in your photo, bio and links from Instagram, TikTok, YouTube or X, and you can paste in anything else from your Cards.

Does Hiyaly take a cut of my sales?

No. Downloads, tips and paid bookings take 0% from Hiyaly; Stripe's processing is the only fee.

Does Hiyaly have swipeable pages like Milkshake Cards?

No. Your Hiyaly page is one scrolling page. If you want separate pages for different projects, you can make more than one, each with its own plan.

How we checked

We checked Milkshake's own pages on 5 November 2026 and took the homepage screenshot the same week. Spot something out of date? Email us and we'll fix it.